Fotocx - Organizing Images for Efficient
Searching
The goal is to find all images for given criteria, e.g. photos of a
given person at a given place and/or time range, all photos of a
given person, photos from a specified location or event, etc. There
are several ways to organize an image collection to accomplish this,
with advantages and disadvantages you need to understand. The
methods listed here (except for albums) are standards compliant and
will work with other programs that support the same methods. These
are (1) searching based on metadata (dates, ratings, tags
(keywords), geotags (locations), captions and comments, and (2)
searching based on file names or partial names, including directory
(path) names.
Fotocx can search using the following image metadata: photo date,
rating (stars), tags (keywords), geotags (location names and earth
coordinates), and text appearing in captions or comments. Searching
based on file and directory names can also be combined with metadata
searching. Any other metadata can also be searched, although not
nearly as fast as the items listed, which are duplicated in a
special index file for fast searching. A strong computer can search
images for the listed metadata items and file names at a speed
exceeding 50,000 images per second.
All of the search methods described below can be used in
combination. The output of a search function can be the input of
another search function (to further narrow the search), and search
outputs can be added to prior searches.
The following is an overview of the different ways images can be
made searchable.
Directory and File Names
These can be used as a basic organization that will enable you to
find images even if more effective organizations (tags, captions)
are not used. The highest physical organization should be by time,
because this will naturally group photos together that are related.
I suggest using one subdirectory per year named 2001, 2002, etc.
This will also prevent any one subdirectory from getting too big.
Optionally, image files may be further organized in time sequence by
using MM.DD as the start of the file name. The rest of the name can
be a topic or event, and a sequence number.
Example: /images/2011/08.20 Spitzbergen
23.jpg
This very basic organization allows Fotocx to find files by
searching for years and topics (file names). In the above example, a
search for "spitzbergen" or even "spitz" will produce all the images
of Spitzbergen. Years can be also be searched and combined with
topic searches, e.g. "2012 Paris". The Batch Convert function lets
you rename a batch of photos taken at one location or event by
specifying a template name like this:
"$mm.$dd Spitzbergen $ss"
Month and day (from the EXIF photo date) replace $mm and $dd.
"Spitzbergen" replaces the camera file name (P00123456), and a
sequence number replaces $ss.
Captions and Comments
A simple method of organization is to use captions and comments.
These are arbitrary text strings that can be added to a series of
images in rapid sequence: Start Edit Metadata, open an image, input
some text, press [apply], press [next], input some text ...
Captions and comments are two separate inputs but treated logically
the same. They are searchable: words appearing in captions and
comments can be searched. You can specify persons, location, topic,
etc. for each image and then find them again quickly.
Tags
The most powerful tool is tags, but this is also the most demanding
of organizational care. You can go through your images sequentially
and add tags by clicking on a list of defined tags. New tags can be
defined as needed. Images can have many tags, and can be searched
using AND / OR combinations of tags, also in combination with other
criteria. Tagging is generally fast, needing a few seconds per
image. Fotocx has two methods of adding tags, a "managed" system and
a "random" system. In the managed system, you define tag category
names and the tags within each category. When adding tags to images,
you can point and click from a list of tags organized by category
and alphabetically within category. In the random system, you simply
create tags as needed while you tag your images, following no
particular system and without categories. When you enter the first
few characers of a tag, existing tags that match these characters
are shown in a pick-list which you can click to complete adding the
tag. If there is no match, a new tag is created. Recently used tags
are also shown in a list that can be clicked. Photos made at the
same time will normally be tagged in sequence, and will also share
many of the same tags. The recent tags list helps to speed the
tagging process. Use Batch Add/Remove Tags to add the same tags to
many images. Batch Rename Tags can be used to rename tags in
selected (or all) images. Tags can be searched in any combination,
combined with other search criteria such as a date range or
location(s).
Note that images downloaded from the Internet may have many tags
adhering to no system. You will need to clean these out or redo them
to stop them from cluttering your list of defined tags. If you see
undesired tags in your list of defined tags, it is easy to find the
offending image files and purge or change their tags: use the Image
Search function to find the images, using the unwanted tags as
search criteria, and feed this list to Batch Add/Remove Tags or
Batch Rename Tags. Tags from downloaded files will have no category,
which keeps them separate from tags you define (if you are using the
managed tags method). Still, you should avoid accumulating thousands
of random tags, and it is easy enough to get rid of them whenever
they appear.
Geotags
Use geotags to assign a city or location and country to your images,
and optionally latitude / longitude. This enables all images for a
location to be quickly found. If you use a camera with a GPS
receiver, geotags are added to the image EXIF data, and location
searching is available automatically. Since image dates are also
automatic (in EXIF), images can be searched by date range and
location without you having to enter any data for each image. You
can leave it at this, or add some of the above extras if you accept
the extra effort required. My experience so far with in-camera GPS
is that the location names are chaotic and you may want to sanitize
them (mixed upper/lower case, with/without states or other political
subdivisions, mixed languages, etc.). You can fix the mess with a
little effort: search for the location name you want to change (e.g.
MUENCHEN, BAYERN, DEUTSCHLAND), then process the resulting images
with the Batch Geotags function to change the location name (e.g.
Munich, Germany). Location names can be searched in any combination.
When you add geotags to an image manually, it is usually sufficient
to enter just the city or location name and then press [Find]. If
the location has been entered sometime in the past, it will be
recalled and all geotag data will be filled-in automatically
(city/location name, country, latitude, longitude). This will also
work if only a few characters of the name is entered, e.g. "hono"
will recall the data for Honolulu, if available. When a location is
entered for the first time, enter the city or location name and the
country, and press the [Web] button. A web service will usually find
the latitude and longitude automatically. If not, you can use
Wikipedia or other web services to find the location coordinates and
enter them manually.
Images with geotags are also searchable by clicking markers on a
world map. The markers are automatically added to the map for all
images containing geotag coordinates. The map can be zoomed to any
scale from street-level to planet level.
Albums
Another method of organization is to use Albums. Choose a name for
each album and assign any desired images to the album by clicking
thumbnails in gallery pages. The images are not duplicated: the
album is simply an ordered list of file names. Albums can be
selected by name and viewed as a gallery of thumbnails. These can be
rearranged via thumbnail drag and drop. The images can then be
viewed sequentially using keyboard arrow keys, randomly by clicking
thumbnails, or as a slide show with animated transitions between
images. Albums are also implemented in some other photo management
apps, but each one is different and incompatible.
The image search function can be used to find images to start a new
album, and then images can be added, removed, and rearranged as
needed. Images can be added simply by clicking gallery thumbnails as
you browse your image collection.
Summary
The following is a summary of some ways to organize a large image
collection, with factors to consider when choosing which methods you
want to use. In the list below, "search by" specifies which search
criteria can be used with each option. Many of the methods below can
be combined, and the possible search criteria increases accordingly.
Searching by photo date (EXIF) is available with any organization.
Images Organized by Topic
- images are in a topic-named directory (a very common practice)
- e.g. /.../Susan 8th birthday/P00123456.jpg
(file
names from camera)
- e.g. /.../Paris 2014/Notre Dame 12.jpg
(meaningful file names added)
- fast implementation: no work if this is your starting point
- gallery view is by topic only (poor overview of a large image
collection)
- search by: topic (using directory and file names)
- no overview of available search topics
Images Organized by Year and Topic
- e.g. /.../2014/Italy/Rome-12.jpg
- e.g. /.../2014/Susan Wedding/P123456.jpg
- fast implementation: move your topic directories into year
directories
- gallery overview by year and by topic within year
- search by: topic (using directory and file names)
- no overview of available search topics
Images Organized by Year, Month, Day and Topic
- e.g. /.../2014/08.22 Rome-12.jpg
- use Batch Convert to format new names from existing groups of
image files
- natural grouping of related images
- gallery overview by year, in time order, with topics visible
- search by: topic (using file names)
- no overview of available search topics
Image Directory and File Names Contain Topics
- e.g. /.../travel/2014/Italy/Rome-Susan-Coliseum.jpg
- many folks have done this, to search for images using a file
search utility
- you may end up with thousands of folders with a few images
each
- search by: topic (using directory and (partial) file names)
- no overview of available search topics
Captions and Comments
- e.g. "Susan 2014, Coliseum in background"
- simple and easy to use
- moderately fast implementation: 10+ seconds per image
- risk inconsistent names, unreliable search
(e.g. search "Rome" would miss the example above)
- search by: captions and comments (any contained word or words)
- no overview of available search topics
Managed Tags
- e.g. "Rome, Italy, Susan, birthday"
- point and click in a tag list to add tags to images
- tags have categories for faster visual location of tags to
click
- typing a few characters is usually enough to retrieve a
defined tag
- recent tags are also available for fast reference and re-use
while tagging images
- no inconsistent or redundant tags, no typos to make searches
unreliable
- requires careful planning of tags - later revisions are
cumbersome
- batch add / delete / rename is available for tag revisions
- search by: tags in any combination
- good overview of available search topics (tags organized by
category)
- tag categories are not standard - they will not be visible in
other applications
Random Tags
- no tag organizing system, tags created as needed while tagging
images
- legacy tags can be kept unchanged
- typing a few characters is usually enough to retrieve a tag
that has been used before
- recent tags are also available for fast reference and re-use
while tagging images
- risk inconsistent tags (scenery, landscape), redundant tags
(Susan, Sue), and typos
- search by: tags in any combination
- overview of available search topics: one large pile of tags in
alphabetic order
Geotags
- e.g. Rome, Italy, 41.89 N, 12.48 E
- cameras with GPS store this data automatically in images
- you can manually add locations (5-10 seconds per image)
- you can batch add geotags to many images at once
- inconsistent location names from cameras (fixable using search
and batch update)
- map markers are generated automatically from image geotag data
- search by: location (city, park, monument ...) and country
- good overview of available search topics: clickable table of
locations [+ date groups]
- you can also click on a map marker to show a gallery of images
at location
Albums
- album names like this: favorites, best scenery, Italy 2014,
Susan childhood
- albums are a list of contained image files, which are not
duplicated
- make albums using any criteria, containing any images
- images can be in multiple albums or multiple times within an
album
- images can be arranged in an album by dragging thumbnails to
position
- add images by selecting / dragging gallery thumbnails to album
gallery
- albums are the basis for the slide show function
- overview of available albums - click on album name to view
gallery
- albums are only usable within Fotocx (there is no standard for
albums)